Drug Channels delivers timely analysis and provocative opinions on pharmaceutical economics and the drug distribution system. Drug Channels reaches an engaged, loyal and growing audience of more than 100,000 subscribers and followers. Learn more...

Thursday, September 21, 2006

Wal-Mart's Generic Pricing Will Trigger Big Changes

Big news from Bentonville: Wal-Mart will sell generic drugs for $4 per 30-day prescription supply. (Summary from today’s online WSJ: Wal-Mart Cut's Prices for Many Generics to $4.)

Yes, you heard right - less than a triple grande non-fat caramel machiatto at Starbuck’s! (So now, dear reader, you’ll know what to order when you meet me in person.) Check out Wal-Mart’s full announcement, which has some additional details.

Folks, we are witnessing a triggering event in real-time. I think Wal-Mart’s move will create massive change in the U.S. pharmaceutical distribution system because it threatens our current system of cross-subsidization.

In May, I pointed out that profits on generic drugs now subsidize the distribution of much more expensive branded pharmaceuticals. (Click here to read my original post.) All the major players in drug channels – PBMs, wholesalers, and retailers – generate higher profit margins and more profit dollars per script from generics. Wal-Mart has been anticipating this unbundling for some time, as indicated by the December 2004 testimony of Frank Segrave, then-VP of Wal-Mart’s Pharmacy division, which was titled “Medicaid Prescription Drug Reimbursement: Why The Government Pays Too Much.” (Subtle, huh?)

Wal-Mart began repositioning its pharmacy department with consumers this summer through the “Pharmacy at Wal-Mart” campaign. They need to convince consumers that a mass merchant pharmacy is just as good as the category killer chains (CVS and Walgreens), but more convenient for the one-stop shopping. By adding the price angle, Wal-Mart provides another benefit for consumers while simultaneously unbundling and attacking the profit streams of competitors and suppliers.

Some initial predictions:

Chain margins will shrink. Wal-Mart is really aiming at the big 3 pharmacy chains, essentially forcing them to blink and lower their margins on generics, too. CVS and Walgreens have less room to maneuver because pharmacy is the biggest chunk of revenues at the chains (70% at CVS, 65% at Walgreens) versus less than 10% at Wal-Mart. PBMs could also get caught in a margin squeeze if payers question their generic margins versus Wal-Mart. And some consumers may prefer to pay cash rather than processing through their benefit manager and paying a co-pay.

The consolidation of retail pharmacy will accelerate. Just look at what has happened to the retail grocery industry. Wal-Mart has used its proprietary distribution system to grab a nearly 20% share of U.S. retail grocery sales in only 10 years, triggering an intense shakeout among regional chains and independents grocers.

Wholesalers will suffer as independents fight for survival. Large chains purchase generics directly from manufacturers, while small chains and independent pharmacies purchase primarily through wholesalers. (Wal-Mart’s largest wholesaler for branded products did not mention any large chains when raving about its generic growth opportunities in June.) Wal-Mart’s move will shift generic market share away from independents, particularly in rural counties that have low chain pharmacy penetration. Recall that wholesalers and their customers will be splitting a maximum generic profit pie (AMP+250%) after Jan. 1. (See my June post on AMP.)

Manufacturers face tough fee-for-service negotiations in 2007. Large branded pharma manufacturers have been able to negotiate very good fee-for-service deals, due in part to wholesalers’ willingness to cross-subsidize services with higher margins from smaller branded companies and generics. I predict that the next round of fee-for-service negotiations will be much more contentious as wholesalers ask manufacturers to plug the gaps.

Check back in 18 months and I'll let you know whether my predictions came true.

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

Reimportation and Homeland Security are strange bedfellows

Read this article: Drug reimportation language holds up homeland security bill

I'm clearly not wise in the ways of Washington because this debate seems foolish. Business practices have led to a sharp drop in secondary market activity in the U.S. (Drug Store News recently referred to pedigree as a "solution in search of a problem.")

So how does encouraging diversion increase our security? I've blogged about the problems of secondary markets often. Rather than repeating myself, just look at my posts under the Drug Counterfeiting topic category.

And file this DC debate under "Things that make you go ... Huh?"

Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Contrarian Views on RFID

Looks like RFID is a sensitive topic!

I got some strongly worded emails about my post on RFID in supermarket pharmacies, especially my comment that "...we have a long way to go before this technology has any impact on supply chain security." (That quote was also highlighted by FDA News in their Blog Watch.)

For another contrarian viewpoint, read the fascinating article by Industry Week columnist Paul Faber called "RFID Market Continues To Move Sideways". His main points:

  • "The major retail compliance initiatives are moving forward at a steady pace, but well below previous expectations/hype."
  • "The innovations that we see due to RFID technology are still largely due to pursuit of realistic goals in custom projects that address a specific need and provide an unambiguous return on investment."
Faber is especially cynical about IBM's recent announcements regarding RFID in pharma. Recall that IBM's press release got Paul Chang from IBM talking about RFID on CNBC , where he claimed that the pharmaceutical industry "...is rallying around this technology." (Yes, that's an exact quote -- I bought the transcript.)

I find it hard to reconcile Mr. Chang's (self interested) optimism with the comments from outgoing Pfizer CEO Hank McKinnell, who said "RFID is not ready for prime time anywhere." Mr. McKinnell also notes that "It does give you control [up] to the first person you ship to. But if that person subdivides, or the pharmacist subdivides, you've lost control." (The whole interview is worth reading -- see the article in July's Pharmaceutical Executive magazine.)

I'll add that track-and-trace breaks down if the person decides not buy from a legitimate source, which is the topic of my popular post on our demand-side counterfeit drug problem.

The FDA and state legislatures are sincere in their interest to secure the pharmaceutical supply chain with track and trace technologies. But we should not let technology hype overcome the real world of patients and pharmacies. The law of unintended consequences will come back and bite us hard.

Then again, I fly over 100,000 miles per year yet I'm not allowed to bring toothpaste on a plane. I wonder how well things will work if we let a giant government bureaucracy take charge of a pharma supply chain track-and-trace database?

If you are brave, feel free to leave comments, rants, and flames in the comments below. If not, just email me directly.

Sunday, September 10, 2006

Supermarkets, RFID, and Wholesalers

The Food Marketing Institute just released their latest annual survey of supermarket pharmacies. (See the Drug Topics summary.) The data shed light on the changing retail pharmacy market, especially margins and RFID use.

First, some context:

  • Supermarkets made up 12% of 2005 retail pharmacy sales dollars.
  • Supermarkets dispensed 470 million prescriptions in 2005, which is up 170%since 1992. For comparison, mass merchants (like Wal-Mart and Costco) dispensed only 365 million prescriptions, up only 96% since 1992.
  • The biggest supermarkets with pharmacies -- Kroger, Supervalu, Safeway, and Albertsons – equal more than half of all supermarket pharmacy spending.
The FMI data come from 46 food stores operating 4,742 pharmacies, which is about half of the 9,800 supermarket pharmacies in the US. Here are few factlets from the survey:

  1. Pharmacy contributes 9% of total store sales, which is about double the percent of sales from 8 years ago. The industry average mix (of stores with and without pharmacy) is 3% of sales.
  2. The “median of the average gross margin” for the pharmacy department was 19.6%. I find this interesting because chain pharmacies do not release any information about pharmacy margins which I presume to be roughly comparable.
  3. No companies are using RFID at a store level, suggesting that we have a long way to go before this technology has any impact on supply chain security. Only 4.9% plan to implement the technology in the pharmacy. I remain skeptical about the uptake of RFID at the pharmacy level, even though it could be an important way to stop counterfeiting on the demand-side.
  4. The ongoing strength of supermarket pharmacy is good news for chain-oriented drug wholesalers such as Cardinal Health and McKesson. According to IMS channel data, supermarkets are much less likely to get bulk/warehouse deliveries from wholesalers than chain pharmacy. As I point out in my post about the Rite-Aid-Brooks/Eckerd deal, wholesalers have become dangerously dependent on low-margin deliveries to the warehouses of large retail pharmacy chains. Even supermarkets with good self-warehousing networks rely more on direct-store delivery since pharmacy is a minority of sales.

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

Big Win for GSK Could Bring Fee-for-Service to Europe

Wow! A big win for GSK announced in its long-running challenge to parallel trade. The official press release is more subdued: GlaxoSmithKline receives positive decision in Greek parallel trade case.

Wholesaler groups and their advocates have long argued that any form of commerce management in the EU is abusive per se under Article 82 of the EC Treaty. GSK’s win recognizes that a pharmaceutical manufacturer has the right to protect its legitimate commercial interests via strategic channel management. Click here for a good summary of the legal issues from Pharma Times.

This ruling could turn the tide on parallel trade because manufacturers can now apply some of the lessons from the US drug wholesaling experience with fee-for-service and inventory management agreements.(See my August 2006 archive for two posts on European drug channels).

The structure of European wholesaler compensation requires a different approach than the fee-for-service agreements used in the U.S.

  • Sell-side margins for European wholesalers are regulated or set by governments.
  • Manufacturers operating in Europe have no history of directly compensating wholesalers for specific behaviors or outcomes.
  • Branded manufacturers directly control only one-quarter of EU wholesaler margins versus 90%+ for US wholesalers, giving them less power to demand a fee-for-service model.
Other models from the US can also be adapted to the EU, such as a dual pricing model in which a manufacturer charges different prices for national sales versus exports. Wholesalers get a rebate to a lower price if the product was proven to be sold domestically. Thus, dual pricing by a manufacturer is analogous to the U.S. “chargeback” reconciliation process.

Bottom line: life just got a lot more interesting for international drug wholesalers!

Tuesday, September 05, 2006

BuySafeDrugs.info = An Uphill Battle

I received an email today in response to my last post reminding me that the pharma industry is trying to solve Problem One by educating consumers about the dangers via a counterfeit drug education website.

PhRMA operates BuySafeDrugs.info “...to provide information on safe, legal ways patients can save on prescription drugs, to educate patients on the risks of importing medicines, and to explain why legalizing importation is bad public policy. The site was designed to be a clearinghouse for the latest news, policies, opinion and research on prescription drug importation and provides news alerts and information about alternatives to importation.”

I have this site bookmarked as a good reference for breaking news on counterfeit drugs. The site doesn’t hide its partisan viewpoint, as evidenced by the multiple links trumpeting last week’s FDA release. Nevertheless, the Harris/WSJ poll implies that PhRMA faces an uphill battle to convince consumers about the dangers of cross-country importation.

Monday, September 04, 2006

Our Demand Side Counterfeit Drug Problem

Let’s return to a perennial favorite topic of this weblog: What can be done to stop counterfeit drugs given the economic and market realities of the drug channel?

The supply side solution to counterfeits is well-known – prevent counterfeits from entering the wholesale supply chain by putting counterfeitors in jail, monitoring the channel, and requiring all wholesalers to source properly.

But what about the demand side problem: How do we stop pharmacy buyers and consumers from purchasing outside of a theoretically secure supply chain?

Three Rules

For the sake of argument, let’s assume that we had a perfect system for tracking every dose of medicine from a manufacturer’s plant to a pharmacy (open or closed door). This is not realistic for many years (if ever), but play along with me and assume that our wildest RFID fantasies come true. (I’ll return to RFID fantasies later this month.)

There are still three rules that have to be followed for such a system to actually make us safer:

  1. Pharmacy buyers must demand pedigree documents (electronic or paper) from wholesalers and be able to validate the authenticity of these documents.
  2. Pharmacy buyers must only purchase from wholesale distributors in the “Normal Distribution Channel” or wholesale distributors that are willing and able to supply pedigree.
  3. Consumers must (a) refuse to do business with any pharmacy that does not adhere to the preceding two rules, and (b) be able to validate a pharmacy’s compliance with these rules.
The National Association of Boards of Pharmacy Model State Pharmacy Act and Model Rules for Licensure of Wholesale Distributors clearly cover Rules 1 and 2 by outlining various “Criminal Acts” associated with knowingly handling counterfeit drugs.

That leaves us with at least two major consumer behavior problems that are as yet unsolved.

Problem 1: Consumers need to stop buying from pharmacies that do not follow Rules 1 and 2.

Right now, that’s pure fantasy. The Harris/WSJ poll released last Thursday found that only 9% of Americans feel strongly that “a law prohibiting pharmaceutical imports from Canada and other countries helps protect Americans from potentially harmful drugs.” Even more troubling, 11% report buying drugs from a foreign country (by going there, on the Internet, or by mail), which is double the percentage in 2002.

Last week’s Mediplan bodyslam by the FDA provided more evidence about the dangers of personal importation, but is anyone listening? Mediplan’s founder would not say where the drugs ship from, but readers of this blog know that wouldn’t tell us much anyway in a world of massive parallel trade.

There’s a good post at Envisioning 2.0 on the communication challenge ahead, although Fard forgets to note the cosmic irony of July’s US Senate vote.

Problem 2: Consumers need to be able to validate safe sourcing practices.

I guess this only applies to the apparent minority who know or care, but we also have a classic principal-agent problem. How can I (the principal) guarantee that my agent (the pharmacy) is acting in my best interests given that I do not have perfect information about the pharmacy’s sourcing behavior? IOW, how do I know that the pharmacy follows rules 1 and 2, thereby minimizing my risk of getting a counterfeit product when I pick up my prescription?

Obviously, not shopping in Canada is a good place to start. But how do I know that my local pharmacy is playing by the rules? As an industry insider, I’m aware of what the industry has done. (See my June post on the FDA’s counterfeiting report.) Yet even I wondered a bit when I recently picked up a prescription for my daughter.

Just say No?

Despite the techno-hype, RFID monitoring will not solve these demand-side problems because it is simply not practical to monitor all 160,000 unique points of drug dispensing to make sure they abide by “safe sourcing” rules.

The bigger political question: will the industry really spend billions to solve this problem when consumers can’t even be bothered to avoid obvious sources of counterfeit drugs? Apparently not, if you believe last Friday’s WSJ cover story on FDA user fees stating that pharmaceutical and biotech companies “…have balked at other FDA suggestions that would, among other things, route user-fee money toward fighting drug counterfeiting.”

Paging La Toya Jackson?

Thursday, August 24, 2006

Rite-Aid + Brooks-Eckerd: Will three wrongs make it Rite?

So much for taking the rest of August off!

As you all know by now, Rite-Aid plans to buy Brooks and Eckerd stores. Following this deal, Rite-Aid/Brooks-Eckerd will become the third-largest store-based pharmacy, jumping ahead of Wal-Mart.

My thoughts:
  • Good for Rite-Aid
  • Better for PBMs and payers
  • Bad for wholesalers
  • Potentially bad (over the next few years) for the chain pharmacy industry

Impact on Retail Pharmacy

Retail chains need scale so they can control access to patients and gain leverage against the payers, PDPs, and PBMs that want access to this network. As I point out in my June 8 dead canaries post, CVS and Walgreens are both trying to grab market share as quickly as possible. Chains with strong store loyalty and a high share of outlets in a given geographic market can negotiate better reimubrsement rates.

For reference, here is our breakdown of 2005 retail pharmacy sales by channel and company.

RetailPharmacy-2005.pdf

Ironically, this move may turn out to be negative for the chain pharmacy industry. The Rite-Aid/Brooks-Exckerd combination creates a credible third large chain pharmacy that PBMs and payors can play off against CVS and Walgreens. The presence of three big suppliers in a market creates much more competitive pressure, as wholesalers have discovered to their regret.

What about wholesalers?

As far as I know, both Rite-Aid and Brooks-Eckerd are McKesson customers, which means that there will be no meaningful volume movement between wholesalers. The deal will create even more customer concentration for McKesson, whose top two customers are CareMark and Wal-Mart.

Nevertheless, this deal creates risk because wholesalers have become dangerously dependent on these low margin power customers. Retail chains such as CVS, Walgreens, and Wal-mart have developed self-warehousing capabilities for distributing drugs to individual stores from their own warehouses. They act as their own wholesaler for generics and many OTC/CPG products.

In Q2, deliveries to customer’s warehouses were 49% of Cardinal’s Pharma Distribution & Provider Services revenue and 32% of McKesson’s Pharmaceutical Solutions revenue. Wholesalers rationalize these sales by arguing it incremental business that would otherwise go direct (true) and generates a reasonable return of capital (insufficient disclosure to verify this claim). Last year, I argued that changes in the drug channel could shift this business back to direct sales. (See my September 2005 white paper Preparing for the Future Retail Pharmacy Supply Chain.) Still a risk, in my opinion.

The Sink to the Bottom Line?

Let’s face it – Rite-Aid, Brooks, and Eckerd are notorious underperformers in retail pharmacy. Yes, things have improved, but none of the companies are as well run as CVS or Walgreens. As one industry executive quipped to me this morning: “If you tie two rocks together, they still won’t float.” Nonetheless, the deal makes sense given the marketplace dynamics.

That’s all for now. Back to my vacation from blogging!

Monday, August 21, 2006

Why so few posts?

I apologize for the unusually long delay between posts. I’ve found myself unexpectedly busy with client work this month. I am also finishing up the manuscript for the next edition of Facing the Forces of Change, a major supply chain trend report sponsored by the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors. (Both HDMA and HIDA are part of NAW.) The report covers the entire US economy, not just health care. The last edition came out in 2004, so this will be a major update. I’ll include some links in future posts for readers interested in how other channels operate. Plus, I am trying to squeeze in a little R&R with my (very understanding) family!

That said, things have been pretty quiet on the drug channels front. Topics that I expect to be covering post-Labor Day include:

  • CMS’ retail class of trade guidelines
  • Competitive effects of the PDMA and pedigree
  • The (re)importation debate
  • The changing wholesaler profit model
  • Coming battles over how to best split up the financing pie among drug channel participants
  • The fate of independent pharmacies

As always, I welcome your suggestions and comments on blog topics. In the meantime, have a great August! I'll be back after Labor Day unless some major news breaks.

Thursday, August 10, 2006

Read the Health Wonk Review

Legendary producer Bill Graham once promoted the Grateful Dead with a sign that read: “They're not the best at what they do. They're the only ones that do what they do. Cheers!”

I was reminded of this quote as I read the excellent collection of links in the aptly named Health Wonk Review on The Health Care Blog. The Review also includes a nice citation to yours truly.

Check it out and be amazed at the variety of knowledgeable experts out there.

Monday, August 07, 2006

Curious about European Drug Distribution?

A few people have emailed me over the weekend with questions after last Friday's post about counterfeit Lipitor. (Why is everyone too shy to post a comment?) My analysis was also picked up by at least one other blog. (Thanks, OnThePharm!)

Here are two good resources about the European market:

1) The European Pharmaceutical Wholesale Industry (2005) -- Published last November by the European Association of Pharmaceutical Full-line Wholesalers (GIRP). While unsurprisingly self-serving about the role of wholesalers, this is a mostly accurate factual resource about drug distribution in the EU.

2) Coincidence or Crisis? Prescription Medicine Counterfeiting (2006) -- An edited collection of chapters from the always provocative Stockholm Network. Be sure to read Chapter 5, which was written by Graham Satchwell. He also wrote a book called A Sick Business in 2004 about organized crime's role in pharmaceutical counterfeiting.

BTW, secondary wholesalers have their own trade association -- the European Association of Euro-Pharmaceutical Companies (EAEPC) -- dedicated to preserving parallel trade regardless of the consequences.

Please contact me directly if you'd like to talk privately about the US vs. European distribution models, as they are quite different.

Friday, August 04, 2006

London Calling: Fake Drugs Get Real

The British fake Lipitor scandal continues to expand after an additional recall was announced yesterday.

It’s really a shame that the public perception of pharmaceutical manufacturers is so low that no one believes in the dangers of cross-country importation. As I commented on the PharmaMarketing blog’s recent snarky PhRMA Intern post, just because an issue favors pharmaceutical manufacturers doesn't mean that it's wrong. That's not demagoguery, just reality.

This got me thinking: What can we learn from the European situation that can shed light on the misguided attempts to allow importation into the US? (See my cosmic irony post.) Plus, there’s a special bonus for everyone who reads to the end of this post!

Of course, the secondary market here in the ex-colonies pales when compared to parallel trade in the EU. Multi-billion parallel trading runs rampant within the EU as authorized wholesalers in countries such as Spain and Greece sell to importers in higher priced countries such as Germany and the UK. Products are often repackaged by intermediaries along this supply chain. Mention pedigree, as I did to some European executives recently, and you will get either a blank stare or a hearty laugh.

EU competition policy hinders manufacturers’ efforts to monitor the distribution channels of their products. Direct restrictions on parallel trade conflict with the principal of European market integration, which allows a product available in one member country to be legally distributed in any other country. As a result, manufacturers face ongoing legal challenges using supply quotas, allocation of available quantities, or refusals to supply as mechanisms to limit purchases for export.

Here's my take on the winners and losers in the EU system:

  • Wholesalers & Parallel Distributors are the big winners. Wholesalers and importers/exporters absorb 80% or more of the price differences between countries.
  • Pharmacies also win from parallel trade. UK pharmacies profit from parallel imports because reimbursement is the same regardless of the source of the drug. Thus, a pharmacy can keep the difference between the import price and what they pay to a wholesaler.
  • Government payers, such as the British National Health Service, indirectly benefit from parallel importing because pharmacy compensation rates can be reduced as long as pharmacies can be subsidized by parallel import profits. The NHS even goes so far as to assume a certain level of parallel importing and then claw back some of the profits. The average claw back was 10.4% in 2002.
  • Manufacturers are the big losers, of course. Cross-country arbitrage costs them billions in lost revenue. Their costs also go up because they can not allocate production or distribution properly because market information is so wacky. IOW, Spaniards probably do not consume all of the products shipped to their country.
  • Ironically, consumers receive almost no price benefit from parallel trade, especially in countries with flat rate patient co-payment such as UK and Germany. Yet consumers also bear all the risk when products are counterfeited, mishandled, or inappropriately relabeled.
Bottom line:
Parallel import in Europe is a basically a punitive tax on innovative pharmaceutical manufacturers, with consumers bearing all the risk and getting little of the benefit.

SPECIAL BONUS

Tired of seeing boring old art or pictures of your kids in your office? Then check out this July Pharmaceutical Executive magazine article and the scary mug shots of the bad guys.

Mug Shots of the Bad Guys

What the Bad Guys did
(Hint: If you can't read this page, left-click and then click the box on the bottom right to expand.)

Suitable for framing? Better yet, how about we all send these links to Senator Vitter?