Thursday, July 25, 2013

A Very Cool Look at Healthcare Spending and the Economy

I am smitten with a deceptively simple chart from the New England Journal of Medicine's July 11 issue.

Regular readers know that I love straightforward graphics that capture complex ideas. In The Gross Domestic Product and Health Care Spending, economist Victor Fuchs creates a clever chart highlighting the long-term relationship between healthcare spending and the overall economy. I reproduce the chart below so you can savor it, too.

Among policy wonks, there is ongoing debate about the recent slowdown in health spending. Are we in the beginning of a long-term slowdown, or just a temporary pause? Look at the chart below, and then contemplate one of the most dangerous phrases in healthcare policy:

This time is different.

To generate the chart below, Professor Fuchs plots changes in per-capita national health care expenditures vs. per-capita gross domestic product. (Both data series are adjusted for inflation.) The annual data for each series are smoothed with a 5-year moving average. To make the correlation easier to see, the GDP value for each year is increased by 2.4%—the average gap in growth rates over the 60 year period.


Wow, what an awesome chart!

Fuchs attributes the mid-1990s divergence to managed care. Looking ahead, he dryly notes: “Some observers place great emphasis on the particularly slow growth of national health care expenditures in 2010 and 2011. How useful is the experience of growth over a period of 2 years in predicting the growth rate over the next 20 years? The answer seems to be not at all.” Oh, snap!

CMS made a similar, but less elegant, argument in its annual analysis of national health expenditures. See the “Price vs. Utilization” section in Who Paid For Prescription Drugs In 2011?

Yes, sometimes a picture is worth a thousand models.

Source: xkcd

2 comments:

  1. Anyone care to speculate on the divergence occurring in the 1993 through 2000?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Managed care. See Page 2, right column, in the original NEJM article.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...